Anatomy Of A Song
When I heard your demo for Yellow the first time, I really liked it, but I did have thoughts about the arrangement. Listening back to the alternate I suggested, I realize it makes no sense, but at that moment, for whatever reason, it did. I thought the song should start with a hook, then break down in the pre-chorus before the chorus, to really lift it. You rejected my edits; thankfully, your arrangement was already set in stone in your mind even though it was just a demo. I also thought the melody could vary more and that some of the lyrics needed to change. The next day you emailed a new version with some small tweaks and more production, which I really loved.
Want to read behind the scenes conversations and learn more about our creative process? Consider subscribing!
It didn’t hurt my feelings; sometimes we take each other notes, other times not. I think we know when to push and when to trust the other's instincts. I think we’ve always been natural collaborators and have grown to understand that compromise is what makes Tegan and Sara. We’re a band with two voices, who shuffle toward a middle, rather than stake our ground on the outskirts. We don’t avoid conflict, but we don’t deliberately create it either. We can be stubborn, and we both like to have control, but I think we have come to understand that we need one another and we make each other better — especially when it comes to songwriting. Sometimes there is no need for compromise. Sometimes you just know that something is right, or great, or the way it should be, and I’m glad we seem to mostly know the difference: when it’s time to fight for something or time to get on the same side and fight together.
So, I’m glad you kept your original arrangement for Yellow. I can’t time travel back to the moment I heard Yellow and give different feedback, but if I could, I might suggest speeding it up, just a little. But I’d definitely leave the arrangement as it is.
I Think We're Alone Now is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.